529 U.S. 217 (2000)
The University of Wisconsin is a public corporation of the State of Wisconsin.1 Its Madison campus enrolls some 30,000 undergraduate students and 10,000 graduate and professional students.2 Since its founding the University has required full-time students at its Madison campus to pay a nonrefundable activity fee.3 For the 1995-1996 academic year the activity fee amounted to $331.50 per year.4 The fee is segregated from the University’s tuition charge and deposited into the accounts of the State of Wisconsin.5
The board of regents classifies the fee into nonallocable and allocable portions.6 The nonallocable portion approximates 80 percent of the total fee and covers expenses such as student health services, intramural sports, debt service, and the upkeep and operations of the student union facilities.7 The allocable portion supports extracurricular endeavors pursued by the University’s registered student organizations or RSOs.8
During the 1995-1996 school year, 628 groups had RSO status on the Madison campus.9 To name but a few, RSOs included the Future Financial Gurus of America, the International Socialist Organization, the College Democrats, the College Republicans, and the American Civil Liberties Union Campus Chapter.10 RSOs may obtain a portion of the allocable fees in one of three ways.11 Most do so by seeking funding from the Student Government Activity Fund, administered by the ASM.12 As an alternative, an RSO can apply for funding from the General Student Services Fund, administered through the ASM’s finance committee.13 A student referendum provides a third means for an RSO to obtain funding.14 One referendum resulted in an allocation of $45,000 to WISPIRG during the 1995-1996 academic year.15 In October 1996, for example, the student body voted to terminate funding to a national student organization to which the University belonged.16
RSOs, as a general rule, do not receive lump-sum cash distributions.17 Rather, RSOs obtain funding support on a reimbursement basis by submitting receipts or invoices to the University.18 One RSO that appears to operate in a manner distinct from others is WISPIRG.19 For reasons not clear from the record, WISPIRG receives lump-sum cash distributions from the University.20
In March 1996, respondents, each of whom attended or still attend the University’s Madison campus, filed suit in the United States District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin against members of the board of regents.21 Respondents alleged, inter alia, that imposition of the segregated fee violated their rights of free speech, free association, and free exercise under the First Amendment.22 On cross-motions for summary judgment, the District Court ruled in their favor, declaring the University’s segregated fee program invalid under Abood v. Detroit Bd. of Ed., 431 U. S. 209 (1977), and Keller v. State Bar of Cal., 496 U. S. 1 (1990).23 The District Court’s order enjoined the board of regents from using segregated fees to fund any RSO engaging in political or ideological speech.24 The United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit affirmed in part, reversed in part, and vacated in part.25 Southworth v. Grebe, 151 F. 3d 717 (1998).26 The Court of Appeals extended the District Court’s order and enjoined the board of regents from requiring objecting students to pay that portion of the fee used to fund RSOs engaged in political or ideological expression.27 These conflicts, together with the importance of the issue presented, led us to grant certiorari.28 526 U. S. 1038 (1999).
Whether a public university may charge its students an activity fee used to fund a program to facilitate extracurricular student speech if the program is viewpoint neutral?29
The First Amendment permits a public university to charge its students an activity fee used to fund a program to facilitate extracurricular student speech if the program is viewpoint neutral.30
Yes. The University of Wisconsin exacts the fee at issue for the sole purpose of facilitating the free and open exchange of ideas by and among its students.31 The parties have stipulated that the program the University has developed to stimulate extracurricular student expression respects the principle of viewpoint neutrality.32 The standard of viewpoint neutrality found in the public forum cases provides the standard controlling here.33
The University may sustain the extracurricular dimensions of its programs by using mandatory student fees with viewpoint neutrality as the operational principle.34
The University may charge its students an activity fee used to fund a program to facilitate extracurricular student speech if the program is viewpoint neutral.
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Souter concurs in the judgment but would not impose a cast-iron viewpoint neutrality requirement to uphold the scheme.35 He would hold that the First Amendment interest claimed by the student respondents here is simply insufficient to merit protection by anything more than the viewpoint neutrality already accorded by the University.36 The relationship between the fee payer and the ultimately objectionable expression is far more attenuated than in the union and bar association cases because the student contributor has to fund only a distributing agency having itself no social, political, or ideological character and itself engaging in no expression of any distinct message.37
The parties have stipulated that the grant scheme is administered on a viewpoint neutral basis, and like the majority he takes the case on that assumption.38
Whether the student referendum mechanism of the University’s program permits the exaction of fees in violation of the viewpoint neutrality principle?39
Yes. It appears that by majority vote of the student body a given RSO may be funded or defunded and it is unclear what protection if any there is for viewpoint neutrality in this part of the process.42 A remand is necessary and appropriate to resolve this point and the case in all events must be reexamined in light of the principles discussed.43
The student referendum mechanism appears to permit the exaction of fees in violation of the viewpoint neutrality principle and requires remand for further proceedings.44
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Souter agrees with the majority that the referendum issue was not adequately addressed in the District Court and the Court of Appeals.45 He limits his examination of the case solely to the general disbursement scheme and would say nothing more on that subject.46 The question before the Court is thus properly cast not as whether viewpoint neutrality is required, but whether the students have a claim to relief from this specific viewpoint neutral scheme.47
He would go no further than the viewpoint neutrality already accorded by the University in upholding the program.48