481 U.S. 537 (1987)
Rotary International is a nonprofit corporation founded in 1905 with headquarters in Evanston, Illinois.1 It is an organization of business and professional men united worldwide who provide humanitarian service, encourage high ethical standards in all vocations, and help build goodwill and peace in the world.2 In August 1982, shortly before the trial in this case, International comprised 19,788 Rotary Clubs in 157 countries, with a total membership of about 907,750.3
Individuals are admitted to membership in a Rotary Club according to a classification system designed to ensure that each Rotary Club includes a representative of every worthy and recognized business, professional, or institutional activity in the community.4 Membership in Rotary Clubs is open only to men.5 In 1977 the Rotary Club of Duarte, California, admitted Donna Bogart, Mary Lou Elliott, and Rosemary Freitag to active membership.6 International notified the Duarte Club that admitting women members is contrary to the Rotary constitution.7
After an internal hearing, International’s board of directors revoked the charter of the Duarte Club and terminated its membership in Rotary International.8 The Duarte Club’s appeal to the International Convention was unsuccessful.9 The Duarte Club and two of its women members filed a complaint in the California Superior Court for the County of Los Angeles.10 The complaint alleged that appellants’ actions violated the Unruh Civil Rights Act.11
After a bench trial, the court concluded that neither Rotary International nor the Duarte Club is a business establishment within the meaning of the Unruh Act.12 The court found that business benefits are incidental to the principal purposes of the association to promote fellowship and service activities.13 On the basis of these findings, the court entered judgment for International.14
The California Court of Appeal reversed.15 It held that both Rotary International and the Duarte Rotary Club are business establishments subject to the provisions of the Unruh Act.16 The court identified several businesslike attributes of Rotary International, including its complex structure, large staff and budget, and extensive publishing activities.17 It found that testimony by members of the Duarte Club leaves no doubt that business concerns are a motivating factor in joining local clubs.18 Business benefits are enjoyed and capitalized upon by Rotarians and their businesses or employers.19
The court ordered appellants to reinstate the Duarte Club as a member of Rotary International and permanently enjoined them from enforcing the gender requirement against the Duarte Club.20 The California Supreme Court denied appellants’ petition for review.21 The Supreme Court postponed consideration of its jurisdiction to the hearing on the merits and concluded that it has appellate jurisdiction.22
Whether a California statute that requires California Rotary Clubs to admit women members violates the First Amendment?23
The Constitution protects freedom of association in two distinct senses: the right to enter into and maintain intimate or private relationships, and the right to associate for the purpose of engaging in protected speech or religious activities.24 In determining whether a particular association is sufficiently personal or private to warrant constitutional protection for intimate association, courts consider factors such as size, purpose, selectivity, and whether others are excluded from critical aspects of the relationship.25 For expressive association, impediments to the exercise of one’s right to choose one’s associates can violate the right of association protected by the First Amendment, but any slight infringement is justified if it serves the State’s compelling interest in eliminating discrimination against women, provided the regulation makes no distinctions on the basis of the organization’s viewpoint.26
No. The relationship among Rotary Club members is not the kind of intimate or private relation that warrants constitutional protection.27 The size of local Rotary Clubs ranges from fewer than 20 to more than 900 with no upper limit on membership. About 10 percent of the membership of a typical club moves away or drops out during a typical year.28 The purpose of Rotary is to produce an inclusive, not exclusive, membership, making possible the recognition of all useful local occupations and enabling the club to be a true cross section of the business and professional life of the community.29
Many of the Rotary Clubs’ central activities are carried on in the presence of strangers.30 Rotary Clubs are required to admit any member of any other Rotary Club to their meetings.31 Members are encouraged to invite business associates and competitors to meetings.32 The clubs are encouraged to seek coverage of their meetings and activities in local newspapers.33
For expressive association, the evidence fails to demonstrate that admitting women to Rotary Clubs will affect in any significant way the existing members’ ability to carry out their purposes.34 As a matter of policy, Rotary Clubs do not take positions on public questions including political or international issues.35 The Unruh Act does not require the clubs to abandon or alter any of their service activities.36 By opening membership to leading business and professional women in the community, Rotary Clubs are likely to obtain a more representative cross section of community leaders with a broadened capacity for service.37
Even if the Unruh Act does work some slight infringement on Rotary members’ right of expressive association, that infringement is justified because it serves the State’s compelling interest in eliminating discrimination against women.38 The Unruh Act makes no distinctions on the basis of the organization’s viewpoint.39 Public accommodations laws plainly serve compelling state interests of the highest order.40
Application of the Unruh Act to California Rotary Clubs does not violate the First Amendment rights of Rotary members to freedom of intimate or expressive association.41
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Scalia concurs in the judgment.42
Whether the Unruh Civil Rights Act is unconstitutionally vague and overbroad?43
This Court will not review a final judgment of a state court unless the record as a whole shows either expressly or by clear implication that the federal claim was adequately presented in the state system.44 When the highest state court has failed to pass upon a federal question, it will be assumed that the omission was due to want of proper presentation in the state courts unless the aggrieved party in this Court can affirmatively show the contrary.45
No. Appellants did not present the issues of vagueness and overbreadth squarely to the state courts until they filed their petition for rehearing with the Court of Appeal.46 The Court of Appeal denied the petition without opinion.47 Appellants have made no such showing that the federal claim was adequately presented in the state system in this case.48 The casual reference to a federal case in the midst of an unrelated argument in their brief to the California Court of Appeal is insufficient to inform a state court that it has been presented with a claim subject to appellate jurisdiction.49
The contentions that the Unruh Civil Rights Act is unconstitutionally vague and overbroad were not properly presented to the state courts and therefore are not addressed on the merits.50