481 U.S. 221 (1987)
Since 1935, Arkansas has imposed a tax on receipts from sales of tangible personal property.1 The rate of tax is currently four percent of gross receipts.2 Numerous items are exempt from the state sales tax, including gross receipts or gross proceeds derived from the sale of newspapers and religious, professional, trade and sports journals and/or publications printed and published within this State when sold through regular subscriptions.3
Appellant Arkansas Writers’ Project, Inc., publishes Arkansas Times, a general interest monthly magazine with a circulation of approximately 28,000.4 The magazine includes articles on a variety of subjects, including religion and sports.5 It is printed and published in Arkansas, and is sold through mail subscriptions, coin-operated stands, and over-the-counter sales.6 In 1980, following an audit, appellee Commissioner of Revenue assessed tax on sales of Arkansas Times.7 Appellant initially contested the assessment, but eventually reached a settlement with the State and agreed to pay the tax beginning in October 1982, reserving the right to renew its challenge if there were a change in the tax law or a court ruling drawing into question the validity of Arkansas’ exemption structure.8
Subsequently, in January 1984, appellant sought a refund of sales tax paid since October 1982.9 The Commissioner denied appellant’s claim for refund.10 Having exhausted available administrative remedies, appellant filed a complaint in the Chancery Court for Pulaski County, Arkansas.11 The parties stipulated that Arkansas Times is not a newspaper or a religious, professional, trade or sports journal and that, during the period after October 1982, appellant had paid $15,838.22 in sales tax.12 The Chancery Court granted appellant summary judgment.13
The Arkansas Supreme Court reversed the decision of the Chancery Court.14 On petition for rehearing, the court issued a supplementary opinion in which it addressed appellant’s constitutional claims.15 The Supreme Court noted probable jurisdiction in 1986.16
Whether appellant has standing to challenge the Arkansas sales tax scheme?17
Yes. Appellant has alleged sufficient a personal stake in the outcome of this litigation. The holding of the Arkansas court stands as a total bar to appellant’s relief.20 Appellant paid $15,838.22 in sales tax on Arkansas Times during the period after October 1982 after settling the initial assessment while expressly reserving the right to renew its challenge upon a favorable court ruling.21
The Commissioner’s argument that appellant lacks standing because Arkansas Times fits none of the exempt categories would insulate underinclusive statutes from review, contrary to settled precedent.22
Appellant has standing to challenge the Arkansas sales tax scheme.23
Whether a state sales tax scheme that taxes general interest magazines but exempts newspapers and religious, professional, trade, and sports journals violates the First Amendment?24
A discriminatory tax on the press burdens rights protected by the First Amendment.25 Selective taxation either singling out the press or targeting individual members within the press poses a particular danger of abuse by the State.26 Content-based taxation must be necessary to serve a compelling state interest and narrowly drawn to achieve that end.27
Yes. The Arkansas sales tax cannot be characterized as nondiscriminatory because it is not evenly applied to all magazines.28 Arkansas Times pays the tax because its articles deal with a variety of subjects, while magazines devoted to religion or sports are exempt under the statute.29 The State has advanced no compelling justification that is narrowly tailored.30
The interest in raising revenue does not explain selective imposition based on content.31 The exemption for religious, professional, trade, and sports journals is both overinclusive, covering even well-established publications, and underinclusive, denying relief to struggling general-interest magazines.32 The asserted interest in fostering communication likewise fails because the scheme only promotes communication on favored subjects.33
The state sales tax scheme violates the First Amendment.34
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Stevens concurred in the judgment but declined to join the portion of the opinion that relied on the broad proposition that government has no power to restrict expression because of its message, its ideas, its subject matter, or its content.35 He agreed that the State bears the burden of justifying its content-based discrimination and has plainly failed to carry that burden.36 Accordingly, he joined Parts I, II, III-B, IV, and V of the Court’s opinion.37
Joined by The Chief Justice
Justice Scalia, joined by the Chief Justice, dissented.38 He argued that the tax exemption has a rational basis sufficient to survive ordinary equal protection review because it reasonably relates to encouraging small publishers and avoiding administrative costs that exceed tax proceeds.39 He maintained that the premise equating denial of a tax exemption with regulation for First Amendment purposes is demonstrably erroneous and cannot be consistently applied.40
Tax exemptions, credits, and deductions constitute a form of subsidy administered through the tax system, and a legislature’s decision not to subsidize the exercise of a fundamental right does not infringe the right or trigger strict scrutiny.41 The 4 percent sales tax was not shown to have any significant coercive effect on publication.42 He warned that the majority’s approach introduces arbitrariness into First Amendment law and casts doubt on many common and unquestionably lawful subsidy schemes, such as postal bulk rates for nonprofit organizations and government funding for the arts and public broadcasting.