831 N.E.2d 915 (Mass. App. Ct. 2005)
Since 1981, the defendants have owned and operated the Middlebrook Country Club, a private nine-hole golf course in Rehoboth, Massachusetts, with 120 members and approximately 40,000 rounds played annually.1 In the late 1990s, the plaintiffs, Amaral and Pray, purchased or constructed homes in the adjacent Columbine Estates subdivision, which was developed independently of the golf course.2
Amaral moved into her home in 1998 after purchasing it from the developer, while Pray moved into her home in 1999 after buying a lot and building on it.3 Both plaintiffs were aware before their purchases that their properties bordered the ninth hole, and each had played the course once previously.4
After moving in, they experienced frequent errant golf balls landing on their properties, often followed by golfers retrieving them.5 Amaral replaced a degraded barbed wire fence with a six foot high chain link fence to deter golfers but continued to collect up to a dozen balls on weekends during golf season, amassing over 1,800 balls in five years along with damage to screens, a window, siding, deck, and her mother's car.6
The Prays relocated the planned house site upon discovering numerous balls where their bedroom was to be located.7 Balls struck the side of the Prays' master bedroom, struck Pray's husband while on the roof, and landed with some regularity in the Prays' backyard swimming pool.8
The defendants responded to the plaintiffs' concerns by eliminating one tee, installing "aim left" signs, planting trees, and allowing grass to grow longer on the right side of the fairway, which reduced but did not significantly decrease the intrusions.9 The parties discussed but abandoned plans for shared-cost netting.10 Following a bench trial in Superior Court where the judge found no nuisance and dismissed the complaint without addressing trespass, the plaintiffs appealed to the Appeals Court of Massachusetts.11
Whether the recurrent entry of golf balls from the defendants' golf course onto the plaintiffs' adjacent properties constitutes a continuing trespass?12
Yes. The distinction between trespass and nuisance turns on whether an invasion affects the interest in exclusive possession of land or merely interferes with its use and enjoyment. Here the recurrent and frequent landing of golf balls on the plaintiffs' properties without permission directly invades their exclusive possession, as Amaral collected over 1,800 balls in five years and the Prays experienced repeated strikes on their home, roof, and swimming pool from the ordinary operation of the defendants' course.15 This physical intrusion constitutes a continuing trespass, and there is no cognate notion of coming to a trespass that would bar relief.
The recurrent entry of golf balls from the defendants' golf course onto the plaintiffs' adjacent properties constitutes a continuing trespass.16
Whether the trial judge erred by denying injunctive relief on the plaintiffs' trespass claim?17
In circumstances of continuing trespass, an injunction prohibiting the continuing trespass is the appropriate remedy.18
Yes. Because the recurrent entry of golf balls constitutes a continuing trespass, the trial judge erred in denying the requested injunctive relief on the plaintiffs' trespass claim. The defendants assert no claim of right to propel golf balls onto the plaintiffs' properties.19 The burden of modifying the course does not rise to the level of hardship that would relieve them of the obligation to eliminate the trespass.20
The trial judge erred by denying injunctive relief on the plaintiffs' trespass claim.21