568 U.S. 85 (2013)
In 2009 Nike, Inc., a designer and manufacturer of athletic footwear that included the Air Force 1 line, filed suit in federal district court against Already, LLC, another designer and marketer of athletic footwear whose products included the Sugars and Soulja Boys lines.1 Nike alleged that the Soulja Boys and Sugars shoes infringed and diluted its Air Force 1 trademark. Already denied the allegations and filed a counterclaim asserting that the Air Force 1 trademark was invalid.2
Eight months after filing its complaint, in March 2010, Nike issued a Covenant Not to Sue.3 The covenant stated that Nike would not raise any trademark or unfair competition claims against Already or its affiliated entities, distributors, customers, or employees based on Already's existing footwear designs or any future designs that constituted a colorable imitation of those products.4 Nike then moved to dismiss its own claims with prejudice and Already's counterclaim without prejudice on the ground that the covenant had extinguished any case or controversy.5
Already opposed dismissal of its counterclaim and submitted several affidavits.6 Its president's affidavit stated that Already planned to introduce new versions of its shoe lines. Three potential investors submitted affidavits asserting they would not consider investing in Already until Nike's trademark was invalidated. An Already executive's affidavit stated that Nike had intimidated retailers into refusing to carry Already's shoes.7
The District Court dismissed Already's counterclaim, concluding there was no longer a substantial controversy of sufficient immediacy and reality to warrant declaratory judgment.8 The Second Circuit affirmed, explaining that the covenant was broadly drafted, that it could not conceive of a shoe that would infringe Nike's trademark yet fall outside the covenant, and that Already had not asserted any intent to market such a shoe.9 The Supreme Court granted certiorari.10
Whether a covenant not to enforce a trademark against a competitor's existing products and any future colorable imitations moots the competitor's action to have the trademark declared invalid?11
Under Article III, a case becomes moot when the issues presented are no longer live or the parties lack a legally cognizable interest in the outcome.12 A defendant claiming that its voluntary compliance moots a case bears the formidable burden of showing that it is absolutely clear the allegedly wrongful behavior could not reasonably be expected to recur.13
Yes. Nike satisfied this burden through the terms of the covenant it issued.14 The covenant is unconditional and irrevocable, prohibiting Nike from making any claim or demand against Already, its distributors, customers, and employees regarding the Air Force 1 trademark based on Already's current designs and any colorable imitations thereof.15
Nike had previously taken the position that the Sugars and Soulja Boys were colorable imitations, and the covenant now permits Already to produce all of its existing designs and their colorable imitations.16 Already failed to indicate that it engages in or has concrete plans to engage in activities not covered by the covenant, despite multiple opportunities in the District Court, the Second Circuit, and this Court.17 The affidavits submitted by Already did not assert any intent to design or market a shoe that would fall outside the covenant's protection.18 Therefore, the challenged conduct cannot reasonably be expected to recur, rendering the case moot.19
The covenant not to sue moots Already's counterclaim seeking to invalidate Nike's trademark.20
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Thomas, Alito, And Sotomayor, Jj.
Justice Kennedy concurred in the judgment.21 Both the District Court and the Court of Appeals issued their rulings on the erroneous premise that it was for Already to make the showing that a justiciable controversy remains.22 Here, however, the Court concludes the case must be deemed moot in all events, based on the terms and scope of the covenant and on Already's seeming insistence that no matter how it might be worded, a covenant drawn by the trademark holder cannot moot the case.23
Already appears also to disclaim any need to determine whether there is a real likelihood it will produce a new product that, first, is not a colorable imitation of its existing product line, and, second, might be thought to infringe Nike's trademark.24 Justice Kennedy cautioned that covenants not to sue should not be automatic mechanisms for trademark holders to terminate litigation without risk of adverse adjudication.25 Courts must ensure the trademark holder makes a substantial showing that the competitor's business will not be disrupted by latent threats in the covenant.26 The burden should not force the competitor to expose future business plans.27 In this case, Already's litigation stance made further proceedings unnecessary, and Nike would be bound by the broad reading of the covenant in future proceedings.28