750 N.E.2d 1097 (N.Y. 2001)
On December 7, 1997, a section of the south wall of 540 Madison Avenue, a 39-story office tower, partially collapsed.1 The collapse occurred after a construction project that included putting 94 holes for windows into the building’s south wall aggravated existing structural defects, sending bricks, mortar, and other material onto Madison Avenue at 55th Street.2 New York City officials directed the closure of 15 heavily trafficked blocks on Madison Avenue from 42nd to 57th Street as well as adjacent side streets between Fifth and Park Avenues.3 The closure lasted for approximately two weeks, but some businesses nearest to 540 Madison remained closed for a longer period.4
Plaintiff 532 Madison Avenue Gourmet Foods, Inc. operates a 24-hour delicatessen one-half block south of 540 Madison and was closed for five weeks.5 In the companion action, the two named plaintiffs in 5th Ave. Chocolatiere v. 540 Acquisition Co. are retailers at 510 Madison Avenue two blocks from the building.6 They sued on behalf of themselves and a putative class of all business entities located in Manhattan bounded on the west by Fifth Avenue, on the east by Park Avenue, on the north by 57th Street, and on the south by 42nd Street.7 The defendants in both cases are Finlandia Center as building owner, 540 Acquisition Company as ground lessee, and Manhattan Pacific Management as managing agent.8
On July 21, 1998, a 48-story construction elevator tower collapsed on West 43rd Street between Sixth and Seventh Avenues in Times Square.9 The City immediately prohibited all traffic in a wide area of midtown Manhattan and evacuated nearby buildings for varying time periods.10 Three actions were consolidated in Goldberg Weprin & Ustin v. Tishman Constr., brought by a law firm, a public relations firm, and a clothing manufacturer all situated within the affected area.11 The law firm sought damages on behalf of a proposed class of all persons in the vicinity of Broadway and 42nd Street whose businesses were affected or closed.12 It also sought recovery for a subclass of area residents evacuated from their homes.13
On defendants’ motions, Supreme Court dismissed the negligence claims on the ground that defendants owed no duty for purely economic loss absent personal injury or property damage. The court also dismissed the public nuisance claims on the ground that the injuries were the same in kind as those suffered by all businesses in the community.14 The Appellate Division affirmed dismissal of the Goldberg Weprin complaint but reinstated the negligence and public nuisance claims of the named plaintiffs in 532 Madison and 5th Ave. Chocolatiere.15
Whether a landowner owes a duty of care to neighboring businesses for purely economic losses caused by construction-related building collapses in the absence of personal injury or property damage?16
The existence and scope of a tortfeasor’s duty is a legal question for the courts, which fix the duty point by balancing factors, including the reasonable expectations of parties and society generally, the proliferation of claims, the likelihood of unlimited or insurer-like liability, disproportionate risk and reparation allocation, and public policies affecting the expansion or limitation of new channels of liability.17 Foreseeability of harm does not define duty.18 Absent a duty running directly to the injured person there can be no liability in damages, however careless the conduct or foreseeable the harm.19 This restriction is necessary to avoid exposing defendants to unlimited liability to an indeterminate class of persons conceivably injured by any negligence in a defendant’s act.20 A landowner who engages in activities that may cause injury to persons on adjoining premises surely owes those persons a duty to take reasonable precautions to avoid injuring them.21 We have never held, however, that a landowner owes a duty to protect an entire urban neighborhood against purely economic losses.22
No. The collapses led to city-ordered closures affecting a wide area and many businesses, including the delicatessen one-half block south that was closed for five weeks and the retailers two blocks away. The firms in the Times Square area were similarly affected. The court balanced factors including the reasonable expectations of parties and society generally, the proliferation of claims, the likelihood of unlimited or insurer-like liability, disproportionate risk and reparation allocation, and public policies affecting the expansion or limitation of new channels of liability and determined that extending a duty to all those suffering economic loss would lead to indeterminate liability to an indeterminate class. That class would include hot dog vendors, taxi drivers, Broadway productions, and thousands of professional, commercial, and residential tenants situated in the towers surrounding the named plaintiffs.
Therefore, limiting the scope of defendants’ duty to those who suffered personal injury or property damage affords a principled basis for reasonably apportioning liability.23
Plaintiffs' negligence claims based on economic loss alone fall beyond the scope of the duty owed them by defendants and should be dismissed.24
Whether businesses closed by city-ordered street closures following building collapses can maintain public nuisance claims by demonstrating special injury different in kind from that suffered by the community at large?25
A public nuisance exists for conduct that amounts to a substantial interference with the exercise of a common right of the public, thereby offending public morals, interfering with the use by the public of a public place or endangering or injuring the property, health, safety or comfort of a considerable number of persons.26 A public nuisance is actionable by a private person only if it is shown that the person suffered special injury beyond that suffered by the community at large.27 This principle recognizes the necessity of guarding against the multiplicity of lawsuits that would follow if everyone were permitted to seek redress for a wrong common to the public.28
No. The closures caused the same sort of injury to the communities that live and work in those extraordinarily populous areas.29 The hot dog vendor and taxi driver suffered the same kind of injury as the plaintiff law firm.30 Each was impacted in the ability to conduct business, resulting in financial loss.31 When business interference and ensuing pecuniary damage is so general and widespread as to affect a whole community, or a very wide area within it, the line is drawn.32
Every person who maintained a business, profession or residence in the heavily populated areas of Times Square and Madison Avenue was exposed to similar economic loss during the closure periods.33 Thus the plaintiffs have not shown special injury different in kind from that suffered by the community at large.34
The plaintiffs have not suffered a special injury beyond that of the community so as to support their damages claims for public nuisance.35