Also known as:wants of consideration · absence of consideration · lack of consideration
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
The absence of any bargained-for exchange or value given in return for a promise. A promise lacking this element receives no enforcement as a contract.
Sources & Authorities
How it applies
Common Examples
5
Modification Lacks New Exchange
Wendy Wu chartered a vessel from Winterhaven Logistics for a fixed price. After departure the carrier demanded an extra sum citing rough seas and took a slightly longer route. Wendy refused the added payment. The carrier's demand fails because it received nothing beyond the original performance obligation.
Firm Offer Without Separate Signature
Wellesley Media, a merchant, sent Wolverine Steel a signed writing offering to sell steel at a set price and stating the offer would remain open for sixty days. Wolverine did not separately sign the assurance clause. Wellesley later revoked before acceptance. The revocation succeeds because the assurance term lacked the required separate signature.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Uniform Acts
Restatements
Casebooks
Dictionaries
Uncle's Promise Enforced by Detriment
Winston Ward promised his nephew Wade Watson $5,000 if Wade refrained from drinking and gambling until age twenty-one. Wade performed the requested forbearance. Winston's estate refused payment claiming no consideration. The court enforces the promise because Wade's forbearance supplied the required exchange.
Hamer v. Sidway124 N.Y. 538
Third-Party Payment Promise Upheld
Walter Washington loaned money to a borrower who directed Whitney White to repay Walter instead. Whitney promised the borrower to make the payment. Walter sued Whitney after nonpayment. The promise is enforceable because the borrower's direction supplied consideration between the original parties.
Lawrence v. Fox20 N.Y. 268 (1859)
Subcontractor Bid Relied Upon
Watershed Pharmaceuticals solicited bids for paving work. Star Paving submitted a bid that Drennan used in its own prime contract. Star attempted to revoke after Drennan's reliance. The revocation is ineffective because Drennan's foreseeable reliance on the bid created an option preventing revocation for lack of consideration.
Drennan v. Star Paving Co.51 Cal. 2d 409, 333 P.2d 757 (1958)
Common questions
Frequently Asked
4
How does want of consideration differ from failure of consideration?+
Want of consideration means no bargained-for exchange ever existed to support the promise. Failure of consideration means the promised exchange was given but later proved inadequate or did not occur.
Supporting sources
Does a written release always supply consideration even if the underlying claim later proves baseless?+
A bargained-for written release supplies consideration if the claim was doubtful in fact or law or if the releasing party reasonably believed it might be valid. A release known to be groundless from the outset does not count.
Supporting sources
Can performance of a preexisting duty ever constitute consideration for a modification?+
Performance of a preexisting duty supplies no consideration when the duty is neither doubtful nor honestly disputed. The party must undertake a new legal detriment or forgo a legal right not already owed.
Supporting sources
When does a merchant's firm offer remain irrevocable without consideration under the UCC?+
A signed record by a merchant that gives assurance the offer will be held open prevents revocation for lack of consideration during the stated time or a reasonable time not exceeding three months. Any assurance term on a form supplied by the offeree requires separate signature by the offeror.
Supporting sources
20 N.Y. 268 (1859)Contracts
…verdict of the jury. But it is claimed that notwithstanding this promise was established by competent evidence, it was void for want of consideration. It is now more than a quarter of a century since it was settled by the Supreme Court of this State in an able and painstaking opinion by the late Chief Justice Savage, in which the…