Also known as: engagement ring · engagement-ring · engagement ring gift
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
A conditional gift of personal property typically jewelry given by one fiancé to the other in anticipation of marriage. The gift is recoverable by the donor if the contemplated ceremonial marriage does not occur.
Edith Eberhardt proposed to Edward Everett with a diamond ring and transferred pre-IPO shares while stating the shares were for their future family's security once married. Edward ended the engagement before any wedding. Edith sued to recover both items. The court treated the ring and shares as conditional gifts because the marriage never occurred.
Emanuel Escobar gave Emily Ellis an engagement ring along with a plasma television and audio equipment during their engagement. After the relationship ended without a wedding Emanuel filed a replevin action seeking return of the ring. The court ordered return of the ring as a conditional gift tied to the failed marriage.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Courts treat an engagement ring as a conditional gift given in contemplation of marriage. If the marriage does not occur the donor may recover the ring regardless of who ended the engagement in most jurisdictions.
Supporting sources
Yes. Courts apply the same analysis to other property when the donor's words and circumstances show the transfer was tied to the anticipated marriage. Factors include the type of property the donor's statements and the timing of the gift.
Supporting sources
No. The later sale or encumbrance does not convert a conditional engagement gift into an unconditional one. The donor remains entitled to recover the ring when the marriage fails to occur.
Supporting sources
Donor intent is central. Explicit statements linking the gift to the future marriage such as calling an item a wedding present support treating the transfer as conditional on the marriage taking place.
Supporting sources
…and used the name Francisco. Francisco was aware of and acquiesced in this conduct. In addition, Francisco gave Connell an engagement ring and had a prenuptial agreement prepared. Both parties underwent surgery that had the effect of improving their fertility. Connell served as the manager of the Whidbey Inn until September…