Robbery Force Requirement
Deanna Davenport grabs a purse from Diana Delgado on the street. Delgado resists by holding tight to the strap. Davenport must pull with enough strength to overcome that resistance before the taking qualifies as robbery.
Also known as: disfacit · disfactus · disfigure · destroy
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
An act of undoing or destroying. The concept requires that the force or conduct overcome resistance or create immediate risk of serious harm when applied to property or evidence.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Deanna Davenport grabs a purse from Diana Delgado on the street. Delgado resists by holding tight to the strap. Davenport must pull with enough strength to overcome that resistance before the taking qualifies as robbery.
Drake Logistics produces an email in discovery. Upon realizing it is privileged, counsel notifies opposing counsel. The receiving party must immediately return or sequester the email and stop using it until the court resolves the claim.
Devon Drake, representing a client, advises the client to delete an internal memo that could be used against them at trial. The lawyer's assistance in destroying the document violates the rule against obstructing access to evidence.
Dover Bank owns land that a village rezones to restrict commercial development. The bank claims the change destroys the property's value. The court evaluates whether the regulation goes too far under constitutional standards.
Dakota Industries sells a car with a contract clause attempting to eliminate all warranties. When the buyer sues for defects, the court examines whether the disclaimer language was conspicuous enough to be effective.
Dynamic Solutions is hit with a large punitive award after a car accident. The insurer argues the amount is excessive and destroys due process protections. The court reviews the ratio and reprehensibility factors to decide the constitutional ceiling.
The force used must be strong enough to overcome the victim's resistance. Mere snatching without resistance does not qualify.
Supporting sources
The receiving party must promptly return, sequester, or destroy the information and copies. Use or disclosure must stop until the claim is resolved.
Supporting sources
No. A lawyer shall not unlawfully alter, destroy, or conceal material having evidentiary value or counsel another to do so.
Supporting sources
…Article 1195, not attacked here, reads: "Art. 1195. Destroying unborn child "Whoever shall during parturition of the mother destroy the vitality or life in a child in a state of being born and before actual birth, which child would otherwise have been born alive, shall be confined in the penitentiary for life or for not…