Caroline Messersmith and her nephew Frederick S. Messersmith each owned an undivided one-half interest in three sections of land in Golden Valley County, North Dakota, prior to May 7, 1946. On that date Caroline executed a quitclaim deed conveying her interest to Frederick, but the deed was not recorded until July 9, 1951. Between the execution and recording of this deed, Caroline executed an oil and gas lease to Herbert B. Smith, Jr. on April 23, 1951, which was recorded on May 14, 1951. On May 7, 1951, Caroline executed a mineral deed conveying an undivided one-half interest in the oil, gas, and other minerals to Smith for a consideration of $1,400, and this deed was recorded on May 26, 1951.
Smith defaulted in the action. Seale claimed title as a purchaser without notice, actual or constructive, of plaintiff's claim. Caroline was 77 years old at the time and lived in Dickinson, while Frederick resided in Chicago. The land was not occupied as a homestead and was used for grazing by tenants.
The mineral deed to Smith bore a notarial certificate of acknowledgment, but Caroline testified that no notary public appeared at her home and that she believed she was signing a royalty transfer. Smith testified that the deed was acknowledged, but the notary had no independent recollection of the event. After the transaction, Caroline wrote to Smith on May 26, 1951, offering to return the $1,400 and stating that she should have consulted her nephew, who was a half owner.
The trial court found that the deeds were not procured through fraud or false representation. Frederick brought this statutory action to quiet title against Smith and Seale.
View case