Also known as: Belton rule · Belton search · New York v. Belton · Belton doctrine
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
A bright-line rule authorizing officers to search the passenger compartment of a vehicle and any containers inside it as a search incident to the lawful arrest of a recent occupant.
Officer Clark stopped Brianna Burke for speeding and learned of an outstanding warrant. He arrested her, handcuffed her, and placed her in the patrol car. Clark then searched the passenger compartment and found cocaine inside a jacket on the back seat. The search was valid because Brianna was a recent occupant of the vehicle at the time of arrest.
Benjamin Brooks exited his car and walked toward a store when officers approached him about a warrant. After arresting him beside the vehicle, they searched the passenger compartment and discovered a firearm under the seat. The search was permissible because Benjamin remained a recent occupant whose arrest justified the compartment search.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Bianca Blanco was arrested for driving on a suspended license, handcuffed, and locked in a patrol car. Officers then searched her vehicle and found drugs in a jacket. The search exceeded the doctrine because Bianca could not access the passenger compartment once secured.
Benito Benitez was arrested moments after leaving his parked car. Officers searched the passenger compartment incident to arrest and recovered drug paraphernalia from the glove box. The search was upheld under the doctrine because Benitez was a recent occupant at the time of arrest.
Bradley Banks was arrested near his car and officers searched the passenger compartment under the doctrine. They also seized his cell phone. The compartment search was upheld, but the phone search required a separate warrant analysis because digital data raised distinct privacy concerns.
Beatrice Brown was arrested after exiting her vehicle. Officers searched the passenger compartment incident to arrest and recovered evidence. The court applied the doctrine to uphold the search while distinguishing it from later limitations that tied the authority more closely to access or offense evidence.
It authorizes a search of the passenger compartment of a vehicle and any containers inside it when an occupant or recent occupant is lawfully arrested.
Supporting sources
Under the original doctrine a search was permitted even after the arrestee was secured. Later decisions limited the rule to situations where the arrestee remains unsecured and within reaching distance or evidence of the offense may be present.
Supporting sources
Yes. The doctrine extends to recent occupants who have left the vehicle before the officer initiates contact, provided the arrest is sufficiently connected in time and space to the vehicle.
Supporting sources
Any container found within the passenger compartment may be searched, whether open or closed, because the justification rests on the arrestee's potential access rather than the container's privacy expectation.
Supporting sources
…can be as dangerous to the arresting officer as one concealed in the clothing of the person arrested." Ibid. In New York v. Belton , 453 U. S. 454 (1981), we determined that the lower courts "have found no workable definition of the area within the immediate control of the arrestee' when that area arguably includes…